PR lessons from the Minneapolis Public School District closings

I try not to vent a lot on this blog. I want it to be a productive space. But today, I just need to let it out.

For the last two days my wife and I have been home with our six-year-old son. The Minneapolis Public Schools deemed it was too dangerous for staff and students to attend school due to the extreme cold temperatures (Note: it was in the single-digits below zero in the morning hours with 20-30 below wind chills) and excessive snow (Note: We received 20-plus inches of snow on Saturday). But, this post isn’t about whether the kids should have been in school or not. It’s about the way in which the Minneapolis Public Schools communicated and shared the news that school was cancelled both days, because I believe there are some lessons we can all glean from how this scenario has played out to date.

First, let’s start with the timeline. As you may know, the Twin Cities was pulverized by a winter storm on Saturday dumping 17-plus inches of snow around the metro (want proof? Here’s video of the MetroDome collapsing as a result early Sun. morning). Most of us spent the better part of Sunday digging out.

As we wound down our day, my wife and I watched the 10 p.m. news Sunday night. We both noted (curiously) that St. Paul Public Schools had canceled classes for Monday. But, no word from Minneapolis Public Schools during that same broadcast (I believe we were watching KSTP-TV at the time; and my wife tells me there was no official word posted on the MPS Web site).

At 4:47 a.m. MPS officially canceled school for Monday–here’s the Facebook post alerting folks in case you were refreshing your browser in the middle of the night.

On Monday morning at 6:15 a.m. we get a call–it’s a broadcast voice mail from the director of communications from MPS. School has been canceled. It’s important to note that my son’s school BEGINS at 7:25 a.m.–just over an hour later.

Later, Monday evening, we get another call (can’t pinpoint time on this one). School has been canceled again for Tuesday. Same reasons as the first day. Again, broadcast voice mail from the director of communications. And, I noticed this post on the MPS Facebook page (BEFORE an official announcement from them).

Finally, we receive this email from someone (more on that in a moment) at MPS late Tuesday evening (it’s time-stamped 11 p.m.) explaining that school would be open Wed. and recognizing the staff for all their hard work over the weekend and Mon./Tues.

As you can imagine, as a dual-income family, neither my wife or I were thrilled with MPS’ decision to cancel school two days in a row. However, again, we were far less thrilled in the manner in which this was communicated to us (Note: We are first-time parents here–our son is in kindergarten; just for full disclosure). Allow me to elaborate–and share the lessons I think we can all learn from this experience:

* Think about the timing of your messages–down to the minute. Mainly, I’m talking about the first message here. You send me a message that school is canceled AN HOUR before classes begin! That leaves working parents like us a whole 60 minutes to formulate plan B. For a family in which both parents work (we’re not the only ones obviously), that’s a big problem. We all knew about the storm. We saw the results play out Sunday. Why not share a message late in the afternoon on Sunday? Clearly, people were clamoring for a decision–you saw that on the MPS Facebook page. By announcing it Sunday afternoon, you could have given parents a whole evening to plan our daycare options for their kid(s) the next day.

Also, note the fact that Monday’s announcement of Tuesday’s cancellation went to the general public (via mainstream media outlets) before it was communicated with parents (or, before MPS even communicated it directly with folks via Facebook and Twitter). Why not start with key audiences first (parents) and work out from there?

Finally, note the time of the “explanation” message on Tuesday evening–11 p.m. Who’s up at 11 p.m. to read that message)? Why not send that note at 8 p.m. when parents are just settling in the for the night and checking email after the kids go to bed? Again, think about timing (down to the minute thanks to real-time social networks like Twitter and Facebook) when communicating key messages during challenging circumstances.

* Think about who should relay the message. Both voice mails were from the director of communications for MPS. I have never met this person. However, I have met my son’s teacher. His principal. And a few other teachers at the school he attends. Wouldn’t it make more sense if a message like canceling school came from someone you knew? I realize their are efficiencies the District is trying to achieve by sending out the same message to all parents (and a consistency of message angle, too), but couldn’t you provide a simple template and send to the principals for them to record and send, just like the communications director did? Would it be more work? Yes. Would there be a chance one of the local principals might mess up the messaging? Sure. But, it would be more credible and relevant coming from someone I know and see almost every day.

My bigger concern here is the email. The subject line reads: “Message from the Principal.” But, the email address of the sender (Stever Norlin-Weaver) doesn’t match up with the principal from my son’s school. There’s no sign off. So, who is this message really from? I literally have no idea. That’s a bit of a problem, don’t you think?

* Think about your key audiences when composing the message. I’m looking squarely at the “explanation” message here. The lead is fine (basically, “we’re open tomorrow”). It’s the next paragraph that concerns me. Not one mention of “we’re sorry for the inconvenience this may have caused your family.” Or, “we hope this message finds you and your family well/safe.” But, instead the message immediately recognizes the MPS staff that worked so hard the last few days. Now, it’s fine to recognize your team–in fact, in many ways I applaud MPS for taking this tack. But, that’s really an internal message. I don’t necessarily care about how hard the staff worked as a parent. I care about my kid and me–in that order (sorry–harsh reality, and I think most people would agree if they were honest with themselves). And, oh, by the way, at my son’s school, I didn’t see one person working over the weekend or on Monday. The sidewalks and parking lots were not plowed until TUESDAY. So, for me, that “hard work” message fell on deaf ears. Know your audience when crafting your messages–and think about what’s top-of-mind for them and what they care about.
Viagra To Buy In Toronto. Viagra 27 Years Old. 100% Satisfaction Guaranteed. Free Courier shipping. Fast online consultation. Safe & Secure. Best Quality Drugs.
viagra to buy in toronto, viagra pill free, viagra 27 years old, viagra line prices, generic viagra reviews safe, china viagra powder, toprol viagra interaction, viagra uk london, la dolce viagra, cialis pill yellow

Again, sorry for the rant again today folks. And I don’t mean to come down hard on the MPS–I really don’t. But, as a parent (and a communicator), I’m a bit frustrated. And, maybe more importantly, I do think we can learn a few things from the scenario I’ve outlined above.

What do you think? Am I right in my assessment from a communications perspective? Or, am I a crazy parent of a kindergartner? (Note: I won’t fault you if you say I’m the latter–it’s OK, I know I’m a little nuts when it comes to my kids).

Subscribe to Communications Conversations by Email
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
,
Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

I work for a school in the Communications Department and I am also a parent, so I understand this from both sides. At our school, it's the Communications Department's job to handle the weather alerts. But we can't do anything until the decision has been made, which comes from the administration. So it is very likely that the administration didn't make a decision until 4:30 a.m., then they have to contact the Communications Director, who begins he process of notifying everyone. The process includes contacting the TV and radio stations, recording and sending out the weather alert call, sending out emails (if your school does this, ours does), updating the website (which can generate both a text and an email if a parent has subscribed) and updating social media accounts. This process can take a while. At our school parents, faculty and staff are told to expect a call between 5 and 6:10 a.m. Unless there's something like a water main break that occurs after the 6:10 cutoff, they are notified by then.

As a parent, I understand your frustration. Both me and my husband work. The school should have notified everyone earlier if they knew, which, realistically, it was very probable the school would be closed. But I know schools very carefully make these decisions. Canceling school means making up school at a later date and it's a disruption to classroom time lines, so they really like to make absolutely sure it's the right decision.

As for the principle making the phone call, that's a good point. I know the call gets recorded in the wee hours of the morning, so it is possible the school tries to streamline the process as much as possible. Also,that would be one message from each school in the district, whereas the Communications Director send it out to parents at all schools, also streamlining the process. The email, however, should have read "SCHOOL CLOSED (DATE)..." or something like that. A "message from the principal" is not a good subject line because too many people won't read it. Our school follows a script for the phone call that is recommended by the weather alert system we use, and we adapt that for the email and online updates. We also send these out from the communications office. Parents receive regular emails from our office so they are used to seeing the account in their inboxes.

I can also appreciate the misguided "hard work" message and your annoyance. It seems they got stuck in their own bubble in this case. Out school's primary focus is on the safety of our students and faculty and staff, so we usually say something about canceling for safety reasons.

Hopefully the district will learn from their mistakes. I know we have learned from ours and continually strive to improve.

I hope you're dug out! I'm in Pittsburgh and we've had the cold, but just a bit of snow. Last year we got buried, so I know what it's like to literally dug out of your house. Stay safe and have a Merry Christmas!

I fell asleep Sunday night and I heard that St. Paul was closed on Monday. I live in Burnsville and we rarely close so I figured they must have had a good reason. We heard on WCCO that the roads were too impassable for the buses and that is why school was canceled. We felt bad for the parents, but I am sure every family has a plan in place just like they would if their child vomits at 4AM. Those things are unpredictable too and no parent would send a sick child to school.

Our district has an automated service that contacts every phone number we own at 5:00 AM on the day of a school closure. I like it. It also sends out an email. We had to sign up for the service so we are aware that it is not a personal message. But at 5AM, we just want the info, we don't care who it comes from :-)

From what I know about our district there is no way they want to make those determinations ahead of schedule beccause they want kids in school so very badly - they don't want to take the chance of missing a day of learning.

Thanks for the comment, Erika. To an extend, I think I'm hyper-critical of any organization from a communications standpoint, just based on what I do for a living. So, some of my analysis is seen through that lens. And yes, of course we have a back-up plan in the morning. And I know they want to do everything they can to keep school open, but as parents, we just need a little heads up. And, if that really is the case with the district (and I'm betting you're right), then I'd include that in the message. Why not tell us about your thought process?

I'm in Portland, Oregon and most districts here don't rely on a phone call system or Facebook posts. The information is given to a service that broadcasts emergency closures to local media outlets. So the information is relayed via newspapers, radio, TV and media websites first. Most districts have a policy that they'll send this information out two hours in advance of the earliest school. No information by 90 minutes before? Time to get ready for school.

We recently had school canceled in our area because of a coming snow storm. It had dusted the roads by the time they made the call at 9pm the night before so they thought it was a sure thing. What happened? The next morning, everything looked the same as it had at 9pm. Just a dusting. And school was still canceled, very unnecessarily I may add. This caused some real backlash from parents who had to pay for a full day of daycare or stay home and explain to their boss why they couldn't come in on a perfectly drivable day. Why didn't they wait? Because the pressure to communicate early (like a lot of districts had done and like many parents looking to plan ahead) was too great.

I know it is a pain for working parents but I think, at least when it comes to weather, it is better to err on the side of waiting. And I don't know if I disagree with their method of communication either. Communicating via mass media seemed to have worked well for a long time.

I don't think you're a crazy parent, you have some real concerns. When it comes to weather related closures though, it's always this situation of being as soon as possible but not a moment before. Where's that line though?

Arik- As a working parent, I really appreciate your frustration. Households with 2 working parents are inherently challenged by our school systems. In Berkeley Heights, NJ we rely on an instant alert system (http://www.bhpsnj.org/files/HoneywellInstantAlertCoverSheetforParents.pdf ) AND we have a superintendant who understands the importance of good communication. Of course like any administration, they struggle with when to release information... making sure all the correct parties are in agreement and informed before they can announce a decision.

There definitely IS a better process in place than what you described above. And a better way to communicate it to parents. I especially like your comment to consider the audience and perhaps make note that "we hope this message finds you and your family well/safe."

I like your assessment (and you know I am extremely conservative when it comes to public ranting! I hope that the MPS School system AND other school systems read and take note.

Trackbacks

  1. [...] media types, he mixes the personal with the professional. My favorite post of his was when he critiqued the communications strategy of the Minneapolis Public School District when his son’s elementary school was closed for two [...]