Why do so few men go into PR?

Wed, Mar 13, 2013

HAPPO, PR

I haven’t worked on the client/agency side of PR now for almost four years. But, when I was, I was typically one of a handful (and in a few cases the ONLY) guy on my PR team.

Men of PR

I’m hardly alone. According to studies, nearly 85 percent of our industry is comprised of women.

85 percent.

And among PRSA members, 73 percent are female.

Now, women will be quick to argue that men hold many leadership positions in PR, so the fact that they dominate in terms of sheer numbers means nothing.

However, when I look around the agencies here in the Twin Cities, I simply don’t see that. Beehive PR–run by the uber-smart Lisa Hannum. Weber Shandwick–Sara Gavin and a number of senior women leaders. Padilla Speer Beardsley–Lynn Casey, of course. And, there are a number of great corporate women PR leaders–Kelly Groehler at Best Buy, Gail Liebl at Travelers, and Gabby Nelson at Sleep Number (client) just to name a few.

Anyway, I’m not here to debate that topic–but I do continue to wonder why so few men go into PR at an early age?

I would suggest a few theories:

More money in other professions

Unlike many women (sorry, blanket statement), more men are driven by money (and power). And PR simply doesn’t provide that like other industries do (I’m thinking of professional services like accounting and legal, and the medical profession). Men are simply following the money.

It’s not a “manly” profession

Guys see how PR is portrayed in the media. They see the movies that show women working in PR. It has a reputation now as an industry that’s mostly made up of women. Over time, that has a tendency to feed itself. I think there’s a certain stigma attached to PR–and that drives men away.

They don’t understand PR

PR isn’t one of those professions everyone understands. And, when you’re choosing a major, that’s a big deal. Accounting, law, engineering, financial services. These are industries that, on the surface, are easier to understand. Therefore, more men are seeking them out.

There’s a generational issue at play

Sons grow up watching their fathers. Many fathers work in industries like financial services, engineering, construction and the like. Those sons grow up watching their fathers, emulating them. And, in turn, they end up going into those same professions. How many 50-year-olds do you know who have daughters in the PR field? I know a number–mostly moms and daughters. Case in point.

What do you think? Why are so few men going into PR today?

Note: Photo courtesy of Judy via FlickR Creative Commons.

Thanks for installing the Bottom of every post plugin by Corey Salzano. Contact me if you need custom WordPress plugins or website design.

Opt In Image
Get Talking Points Delivered Straight to Your E-mail Inbox!

Get Talking Points--my weekly e-newsletter--delivered straight to your e-mail inbox each Wednesday by signing up above. I'll provide you with insightful posts, useful how-to articles and other information designed to help YOU do your job better.

,
Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
VincentHazleton 5 pts

Please get the numbers right. I don't know of any studies which show 85% of practitioners are women. Data from the federal govt., Bureau of Labor Statistics survey of employers and the monthly Current Population survey of the census bureau shows that 60% women and 40% men in PR. In PRSA 71% of members are women not 73%.

VINCENT Hazleton, PhD, APR, Fellow PRSA

Professor of Communication

Radford University

Frank_Strong 258 pts

"It's not a manly profession."  Hmmm.  Not sure what to make of that.   There's no doubt it's dominated by women.  On the agency side, I've always worked for women.  On in house side, the CMO has always been a man.  

arikhanson 74 pts moderator

 Frank_Strong That's the interesting rub--dominated by women, yet men still make up a lot of the senior roles, mostly on the marketing side.

MikeSchaffer 41 pts

Very interesting topic to address, Arik. I just crunched some numbers on my company, of a shade under 50 practitioners (so extracting admin/support) and we are 20% male.

 

For me, I backed into PR in college. I dabbled in print, radio and TV work through courses, internships and activities. While I developed a passion for media, I also developed a passion for a steady paycheck, health insurance and somewhat (ha!) reasonable hours. That led me to PR, where I could work with the media, diversify my client portfolio and own projects.

 

I look at my friends and former classmates who stuck on the media side and see lack of job security, constant movement, years spent in places I would rather not be (no disrespect to some of America's finest hidden gems, but I'm a city mouse) and the inability to take time off. Not my cup of tea, but I'm happy that they are happy.

arikhanson 74 pts moderator

 MikeSchaffer The media path is going to be a tough one to convince kids to take now. Low pay. Fewer jobs. And, like you said, you have to live in some fairly rural communities before (if ever) you break through. PR has it's drawbacks, too. Crazy hours and a low pay ceiling (for some). For the most part, you can't really make a ton in PR. I know salaries at the higher levels go up dramatically, but for the lion's share of the workforce, you don't make a ton of dough in our industry (compared to others, at least).

GeriRosmanPR 6 pts

Arik--interesting piece. Often wonder about this myself. Could it be a left brain/right brain phenomenon? That is, women tend to be more creative, communicative, storytellers and  men are "better" (cough cough!), or guided more frequently to more analytical professions? I think it also takes a certain personality to be in pr -- persistent, outgoing -- traits not always developed in young men. 

arikhanson 74 pts moderator

 GeriRosmanPR Personality types definitely has something to do with it. People scoff at that "manly" comment though, but I really think there's something to that. Go ask some guys some time what they think of PR...

ElissaFreeman 202 pts

Here's my take: PR as an industry needs to create a better public understanding. Ask the average person what he/she thinks PR is...and most will answer "party planning."  Do guys plan parties? No. Well, some do, but not many. In order for the perception to change, we need some really manly men to educate students that it is an equal opportunity profession; that there are many facets to the industry and of the powerful role PR often plays in corporate decision-making. 

arikhanson 74 pts moderator

 ElissaFreeman hence my comment about the "manliness" of PR...

KTress 6 pts

I'd be even more interested to know what percentage of the few men who are working in PR are straight vs gay - not that it makes a bit of difference in the world, obviously, but as a gay man myself working in the field, I cannot help but notice the disproportionate amount of other gay men (particularly in the agency world.)

arikhanson 74 pts moderator

 KTress Interesting. Didn't think about that. You really think the proportion of gay vs. straight men is tilted?

Conversation from Twitter

BenChelliah
BenChelliah @BenChelliah 27 Mar
missy_gi: That's an interesting piece. There is some truth in it, I guess. But why would anyone NOT want to do PR? It's amazing. :)
arikhanson
arikhanson @arikhanson 19 Mar
CoSIDAnews And financial, B2B and a few others...
MoSharee8
MoSharee8 @MoSharee8 19 Mar
CoSIDAnews arikhanson Makes you wonder if sports PR\/MR positions are also included in these studies. Probably won't skew too much though
rturco122
rturco122 @rturco122 19 Mar
alexadig guess I'm an exception!!
alexadig
alexadig @alexadig 19 Mar
rturco122 you got it!!!
aclinkman
aclinkman @aclinkman 17 Mar
joeldon arikhanson As a man in PR, I need to agree. The $$ is a big reason, I'd imagine.
Frank_Strong
Frank_Strong @Frank_Strong 16 Mar
omarjmc arikhanson so the three of us need to get a beer sometime at a conference.
omarjmc
omarjmc @omarjmc 16 Mar
Frank_Strong arikhanson Sounds good to me. Would love to hear your thoughts
kenwheaton
kenwheaton @kenwheaton 13 Mar
rachelakay Yes, I'm being stereotypical, but those are just guesses.
rachelakay
rachelakay @rachelakay 13 Mar
kenwheaton Ha! Well, you may be on to something. :)
kenwheaton
kenwheaton @kenwheaton 13 Mar
rachelakay I'd bet the bulk of men in PR are in crisis PR where they can grunt, front, kick ass and take names and yell
kenwheaton
kenwheaton @kenwheaton 13 Mar
rachelakay I'm going to venture it's because there's too much babysitting, ego-stroking and butt-kissing involved.
arikhanson
arikhanson @arikhanson 13 Mar
kmaverick adamkmiec Also: I'd love to hear from women why they think men don't go into PR.
kmaverick
kmaverick @kmaverick 13 Mar
arikhanson adamkmiec I'm not disagreeing with the . I think the "thoughts on why" are completely ridiculous
arikhanson
arikhanson @arikhanson 13 Mar
kmaverick adamkmiec I know. And I'm asking you what you think about the "whys"
arikhanson
arikhanson @arikhanson 13 Mar
kmaverick adamkmiec And, might I say, those weren't guesses. Those takes were based on convos I've had over many years w\/guys.
arikhanson
arikhanson @arikhanson 13 Mar
kmaverick adamkmiec so you can call them ridiculous, but it's based on what I'm hearing. I never said guys were smart ;)
kmaverick
kmaverick @kmaverick 13 Mar
arikhanson adamkmiec the guy who thinks PR isn't "manly" should go on record then…and the TV comment - come on.
arikhanson
arikhanson @arikhanson 13 Mar
kmaverick adamkmiec I didn't know this was a congressional hearing... ;)
adamkmiec
adamkmiec @adamkmiec 13 Mar
kmaverick still waiting on your thoughts as to why ;) arikhanson
arikhanson
arikhanson @arikhanson 13 Mar
adamkmiec kmaverick easy to criticize. Not so easy to come up with other opinions, I guess...
kmaverick
kmaverick @kmaverick 13 Mar
arikhanson adamkmiec i just think your opinions highlighted stereotypes vs fact. the were great
kmaverick
kmaverick @kmaverick 13 Mar
adamkmiec that just set him back 20 years
adamkmiec
adamkmiec @adamkmiec 13 Mar
kmaverick it is interesting. Data doesn't lie right?
kmaverick
kmaverick @kmaverick 13 Mar
adamkmiec "because women on TV are in PR" - come ON
adamkmiec
adamkmiec @adamkmiec 13 Mar
kmaverick I just mean the raw data. The overwhelming majority of pr pros are female. Ditto with account management.
arikhanson
arikhanson @arikhanson 13 Mar
kmaverick adamkmiec You don't agree with my take? What's yours? Numbers don't lie...
adamkmiec
adamkmiec @adamkmiec 13 Mar
arikhanson hey you know where I stand. The numbers don't lie. I still don't know why it's so slanted. kmaverick
rachelakay
rachelakay @rachelakay 13 Mar
adamkmiec arikhanson kmaverick Geez - I'm enjoying this conversation ;)
arikhanson
arikhanson @arikhanson 13 Mar
rachelakay Your take? Do you think the reasons I laid out are bogus?
rachelakay
rachelakay @rachelakay 13 Mar
arikhanson Not necessarily. PR as a woman's job is a common stereotype. I think that's what you meant by the TV comment.
rachelakay
rachelakay @rachelakay 13 Mar
arikhanson Otherwise I have no idea why more women are in PR.
arikhanson
arikhanson @arikhanson 13 Mar
rachelakay See,I was the opposite. I went INTO PR b\/c of the women. 80\/20 ratio--where do I sign up! :)
adamkmiec
adamkmiec @adamkmiec 13 Mar
rachelakay arikhanson kmaverick statistically per the 4 As there are way more women in account management too. Have no idea why.
rachelakay
rachelakay @rachelakay 13 Mar
arikhanson HA!! You were a smart one!
arikhanson
arikhanson @arikhanson 13 Mar
rachelakay Just playing the odds. Believe me, I needed all the help I could get...
BPLewis
BPLewis @BPLewis 13 Mar
kmaverick Me am man. Me work in finance. Me not want PR job. Me see women in PR on television. Me want to be manly
kmaverick
kmaverick @kmaverick 13 Mar
BPLewis basically i read the entire article with that tone of voice